Popular Science+ Review
+ Universal App
FREE! Buy now!

Popular Science+ Review

Our Review by Zach Sims on June 10th, 2010
Rating: starstarstarhalfstarblankstar :: A LITTLE OFF
Share This:

The Bonnier Mag+ platform is great on video and in theory but isn't great as an iPad application.

Developer: Bonnier
Price: $4.99
Version Reviewed: 1.03
Reviewed on: iPad

iPhone Integration Rating: starstarstarstarblankstar
User Interface Rating: starstarstarblankstarblankstar
Re-use Value Rating: starstarstarstarblankstar

Overall Rating: starstarstarhalfstarblankstar

Popular Science's publisher, Bonnier, greeted the iPad's launch with the creation of their own magazine platform, Mag+. Popular Science+ is the first application to launch on the new platform. The app seems to have inspired Wired's navigation scheme as it utilizes a similar horizontal and vertical workflow. In-app purchasing allows users to get new issues for $4.99 (last month) or $2.99 (earlier issues).

[caption id="attachment_38230" align="alignright" width="300" caption="PopSci\'s What\'s New page"]

[/caption]The app is ambitious, as it tries to introduce many new UI features with a series of instructions for the reader. It is, however, far too complicated for the average reader. I found myself confused after using the app for a couple of minutes. Tapping the left side of the screen makes it easier to view the images by making the text disappear. Clicking the right side brings the text back. My favorite section of Popular Science, "What's New," is impossible to navigate in the iPad version. Scrolling between products is complex - do you move down or to the side and how far do you have to scroll? PopSci+ tries to introduce new UI elements where they're seemingly not necessary. Not only does scrolling vary as mentioned earlier, but moving between products in the "What's New" section changes the background photograph.

Popular Science is one of my favorite magazines, and the early promotional videos for Mag+ got me very excited about the potential of magazines on the iPad. In fact, the vision promoted by Mag+ is a large reason for my iPad purchase. Bonnier's Mag+, however, looks terrific in theory but needs a lot of perfecting before it's ready for the prime time.

iPhone Screenshots

(click to enlarge)

Popular Science screenshot 1 Popular Science screenshot 2 Popular Science screenshot 3 Popular Science screenshot 4 Popular Science screenshot 5

iPad Screenshots

(click to enlarge)

Popular Science screenshot 6 Popular Science screenshot 7 Popular Science screenshot 8 Popular Science screenshot 9 Popular Science screenshot 10
Share This: