Apple Issues Response to Lodsys' Patent Claims Against Individual Developers

Posted by Carter Dotson on May 26th, 2011
iPhone App - Designed for iPhone, compatible with iPad

Apple has finally responded to patent holding firm Lodsys' claims against developers using in-app purchases in their apps. The gist of the story so far is that Lodsys has a patent that it claims covers the mechanism the App Store apps use to offer in-app purchases. Apple pays a fee to Lodsys to cover the use of in-app purchases, but Lodsys has gone after a series of individual developers, including the developer of PCalc, asking for a fee to use in-app purchases in their own apps. Apple has been silent on the matter for the last week, prompting one analyst covering the matter to say that developers who get notified by Lodsys should just appease the seeming patent troll. That was just before Apple finally responded to Lodsys' claim recently, and they responded with sound and fury.

Apple claimed that their licensing of Lodsys' patents extends to developers using in-app purchases in their apps as well, saying that "Because Apple is licensed under Lodsys' patents to offer such technology to its App Makers, the App Makers are entitled to use this technology free from any infringement claims by Lodsys," as according to Apple senior vice president and general counsel Bruce Sewell, in a letter sent to Lodsys and the developers who have been contacted by Lodsys. Sewell also claims in the letter that "Apple is undisputedly licensed to these and the Apple App Markers are protected by that license. There is no basis for Lodsys' infringement allegations against Apple's App Makers." Apple has requested that Lodsys cease and desist their claims against developers they have contacted in regards to these patents.

It will be interesting to see where this issue goes from here on out - will Apple provide legal defense for these developers affected? Lodsys is located near a court that is notorious for being friendly to patent holders, so any legal battle could be tricky for Apple and affected developers. Or will Lodsys just back off of their claims, having awoken the big dogs at Apple after trying to nickel and dime individual developers? Dane Baker of Villain, developers of Archetype, who received a patent infringement notice from Lodsys, claims that "We were sent a notice of patent infringement which implies a lawsuit. None of us can operate on the assumption that Apple is going to provide any help here at all, that's just not smart. In other words it's not Apple's problem when Villain are hit with a lawsuit." Dane also claims that they have spoken to patent attorneys, and that Lodsys will likely sue thousands of developers and "hope for a handful of scared or stupid developers to pay them to go away." This will likely be an issue settled through a lengthy legal matter, so the impact on individual developers could be unknown for a long time.

iPhone Screenshots

(click to enlarge)

Archetype screenshot 1 Archetype screenshot 2 Archetype screenshot 3 Archetype screenshot 4 Archetype screenshot 5
Posted in: News
Tagged With: Apple, In-app purchases, Lodsys, Legal issues
Share This: